Catalonia
Catalan bill against speculative home purchases stalls after PSC and Comuns fail to agree
A legal setback has left the bill uncertain shortly before a vote in the Catalan Parliament, expected in December. The dispute is whether purchases should be tied strictly to main homes or whether town halls should be able to authorise exceptions.
By Damián Ortells ·
Catalonia’s planned law to curb speculative home purchases has stalled because the PSC and Comuns, the two groups that agreed the measure in July, have failed to settle on a shared rewrite. The original text would have banned buying a home unless the buyer used it as their main residence. The exception allowed large landlords or companies to buy entire buildings if they put the homes on the rental market at a capped price.
The turning point was the opinion issued by the Consell de Garanties Estatutàries, Catalonia’s statutory legal advisory body, which checks whether Catalan laws fit the Estatut, Catalonia’s charter of self-government, and the Spanish Constitution. The council found that the proposal clashed with both legal frameworks. Its opinions are not binding on Parliament, but the PSC chose to redraft the bill so that it could go to a vote with stronger legal footing.
That decision opened a rift with the Comuns, who initially wanted to press ahead with the first version to avoid weakening it. After months of talks, and with 30 October as the deadline for filing amendments, the two groups submitted separate changes. The Catalan Government considered asking for an extension but eventually ruled that out.
The Government amendment, led by the PSC administration, drops the idea of limiting how many homes a person or company can buy and shifts the test to the use of the property. The home would have to be used as a habitual and permanent residence, including in the case of new-build flats. The text also creates exceptions: town halls could authorise other residential uses, such as seasonal lets or tourist lets, if they justify that there is enough housing for main residences.
The Government proposal would also allow the buyer not to rent out the flat immediately when the property is involved in an eviction court case or is being renovated at the time of purchase. These cases matter for investment activity, because they can arise in purchases made below market value before the property is later rented out.
The Comuns have mainly registered technical amendments. Their main substantive change would exclude homes acquired through inheritance from the ban. Jéssica Albiach has accused the PSC of stepping back from the agreement and watering down what had been negotiated. Salvador Illa, by contrast, says the agreement has not been broken.
The bill now depends on the vote in the Catalan Parliament, scheduled for December. In its first version it had the backing of the PSC and Comuns, but it also needed ERC, the Catalan Republican Left, which had not given unconditional support. For landlords, buyers and tenants, the rules do not change for now: the real effect will depend on the text that reaches the vote and the parliamentary support it secures.